The Best Butter Tarts in Canada

As voted by Canadian Living Magazine

Holiday Hours

Christmas Eve (Dec. 24): Barrie & Orillia until 4pm, Newmarket until 6pm
Christmas Day (Dec. 25): All locations closed
Boxing Day (Dec. 26): Newmarket 9am-8pm
New Year's Eve (Dec. 31): All locations 10am-6pm
New Year's Day (Jan. 1): Barrie & Orillia closed, Newmarket 11am-6pm

On all other days, we’re open for business as usual!

**Important Update:** Due to high order volumes, shipping is temporarily unavailable until after December 25, 2024. Thank you for your understanding!

Family Owned - A Message From The Owners

Welcome to The Sweet Oven, a family owned and operated business servicing Barrie and the surrounding area. We offer the tastiest butter tarts sure to turn your special occasions into special memories.   Using only high quality ingredients, we create a selection of butter tarts that will amaze even the most discerning palate. Butter tarts are proudly Canadian, and are all hand made from scratch using the freshest ingredients and baked on premise. There are no frozen shells or fillings with our tarts! All are handmade. We offer over twenty different flavours of butter tarts from the traditional Plain, to Chocolate Chip, Coconut, Raisin Walnut and our signature tart Raspberry. They are excellent warm from the oven, at room temperature or even chilled.   The Sweet Oven will bring a new perspective to specialty treats...

Rob & Kerri, Owners
THE SWEET OVEN

Our Sweet Treats

BUTTER TARTS

Monday - Plain, Pecan, Raisin, Butterscotch Chip, Coconut Chocolate Chip, Coffee, English Toffee, Nutella.

Tuesday  - Plain, Pecan, Raisin, Chai, Chocolate Chip, Cinnamon Raisin, Cocoa, Skor Bit

Wednesday - Plain, Pecan, Raisin, Coconut, Coffee, English Toffee, Nutella, Mint Oreo, Peanut Butter

Thursday- Plain, Pecan, Raisin, Butterscotch Chip, Cinnamon Raisin, Cocoa, Coconut Chocolate Chip, Salted Caramel Pecan, Skor

Friday - Plain, Pecan, Raisin, Chai, Chocolate Chip, Coffee, Nutella, Mint Oreo, Lemon, Flavour of the Month

Saturday - Plain, Pecan, Raisin, Blueberry Lemon, Coconut, Peanut Butter, Salted Caramel Pecan, Raspberry, Skor, Flavour of the Month

Sunday - Plain, Pecan, Raisin, Salted Caramel Pecan, Skor, Flavour of the Month

CHEESECAKES

Monday- Plain, Skor, Oreo, Coffee, Lemon

Tuesday - Plain, Skor, Oreo, Chocolate, Chocolate Chip, Raspberry

Wednesday- Plain, Skor, Oreo, Peanut Butter, English Toffee, Coffee

Thursday -Plain, Skor, Oreo, Chocolate, Lemon

Friday - Plain, Skor, Oreo, Chocolate Chip, Half and Half

Saturday - Plain, Skor, Oreo, Peanut Butter, Raspberry

Sunday - Plain, Skor, Oreo, Half and Half

BEVERAGES

SOFT DRINKS: Coke, Diet Coke, Orange, Cream Soda, Grape, Ginger Ale, Root Beer, Pepsi, Diet Pepsi

BOTTLED WATER: Nestle Pure Life

SPECIALTY COFFEE (ORILLIA ONLY): Espressos, Lattés, Coffee, etc

**In-store pickup only**

Eggnog Butter Tarts

Eggnog fans, this one’s for you—you’re going to LOVE these! Pickup a single, build your own sweet 6-pack, or grab a dozen. Whatever your holiday heart desires!

Available Friday, Saturday, and Sunday at all three locations, Eggnog Butter Tarts are here for the holidays!

ORDER IN-STORE PICKUP

Butter Tart flavour of the month

Chocolate Candy Cane Butter Tarts

'Tis the season for Chocolate Candy Cane Butter Tarts! A perfect mix of creamy chocolate and a peppermint twist—just the holiday treat you need to sweeten your season!

Available at all three locations Friday through Sunday in December, so don’t miss out. Stop by and stock up or order in-store pickup online.

ORDER IN-STORE PICKUP

**Holiday Special**

Mincemeat Butter Tarts

Ready for a taste of the holidays? Our Mincemeat Butter Tart is back! Think buttery, flaky crust, spiced mincemeat, and rich, Sweet Oven filling—just the right touch of seasonal warmth for your cravings.

These holiday favourites are available every day in December, so don’t miss out!

ORDER IN-STORE PICKUP

BARRIE AND ORILLIA ONLY

Hot Cocoa Bar

Warm up this season with a cozy cup of hot chocolate, now available at our Barrie and Orillia locations! Build it your way with toppings like crushed candy cane, marshmallows, crumbled Oreo, cinnamon, and more. Plus, pair it with a signature Sweet Oven butter tart, cheesecake, or cookie to really satisfy that craving.

📍 90 Park Place Blvd, Barrie
📍 3220 Monarch Dr, Orillia

Meet our newest sweet treat

The Cannoli

Choose between a classic plain shell ($3.50) or a rich chocolate-lined shell ($3.99), both filled with creamy ricotta goodness. Top it off with chocolate chips or pistachio for the perfect finishing touch! Exclusively at our Newmarket and Orillia locations—don’t miss out! 

ORDER IN-STORE PICKUP

Butter Tarts

Cheesecakes

Find us on Instagram! @thesweetoventarts

Contact Us